Where Revolution was discussed and decided
When Samuel Stuart purchased his tavern property in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, in 1778, he served food and drink with a side of revolution. Like many colonial taverns, it functioned as a hub of political debate, military coordination, and community organizing in a frontier town that sat at the crossroads of war. It also housed prisoners of war.
Carlisle was a strategic inland center for mustering troops, moving supplies, and relaying orders across Pennsylvania. Taverns such as Stuart’s provided essential services to the Revolutionary cause: lodging for officers, meeting space for committees and militia leaders, and informal venues where news from Philadelphia, Boston, and the frontier spread rapidly. Messages were exchanged, loyalties tested, and plans quietly discussed over shared tables and tankards.
During the Revolution, Continental officers, Pennsylvania militia, wagoners, and messengers passed through Carlisle in steady streams. Stuart’s Tavern would have hosted men marching east toward the Susquehanna crossings or west toward the frontier, making it a civilian space deeply entwined with military life. Decisions shaped here—whom to trust, where to move supplies, how to respond to threats—had real consequences once muskets were shouldered and roads taken.
Perhaps most notably, two captured British agents were held here while awaiting trial. Major John Andre and Lt. Edward Despard. Major Andre had been acting under orders from General Benedict Arnold to fortify and defend West Point when Arnold defected to the British in 1780.
Major Andre was later executed while Lt. Despard moved back to England. He was later executed for plotting to seize the Tower of London and the Bank of England.
Though no battlefield lies here, Stuart’s Tavern represents the social infrastructure of rebellion. Independence was not forged solely on fields of fire, but in taverns where ordinary people encountered extraordinary ideas and chose sides. In Carlisle, Stuart’s Tavern stands as a reminder that the Revolution advanced one conversation at a time.
Address: Although Stuart’s Tavern is no longer standing, it existed at what is now 125-127 South Hanover Street, Carlisle.
Access notes: The site of Stuart’s Tavern is now The Salvation Army. Street parking.
Visiting tips: There’s a lot of Carlisle nearby to enjoy, as well as multiple stops on our Patriots’ Path, including the Old Public Cemetery.
Patriot’s Story: Brigadier General William Irvine
1741-1804
William Irvine was not a household name like Washington or Wayne, but in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, he was a familiar figure. A physician by training, Irvine was elected to the Pennsylvania Assembly, and, when war broke out in 1776, he accepted a colonel’s commission in the Continental Army, tasked with raising the 6th Pennsylvania Regiment. Places like Stuart’s Tavern formed the backdrop of Irvine’s early wartime life. Taverns in Carlisle were where officers exchanged intelligence, coordinated militia activity, and debated the risks of rebellion. Irvine moved easily through these spaces—part civilian, part soldier—bridging the world of local politics and Continental command.
Irvine was captured by the British on June 16, 1776 at the Battle of Three Rivers in Canada. After his exchange in 1778, he returned to service and was promoted to Brigadier General in 1779. He later commanded troops on the Pennsylvania and western frontiers, defending settlements and maintaining order in a volatile region.
Resources
Credits & Permissions
Content in this section was curated by volunteers from the Army Heritage Center Foundation.