Resting places of founders, heroes, and legends.
The Old Public Graveyard is one of Carlisle’s most significant Revolutionary War–era sites. Established in 1757, this burial ground preserves the final resting place of soldiers, civic leaders, and local figures who shaped the town during the American Revolution. Visitors encounter a landscape of historic gravestones that reflect both the hardships of frontier life and the ideals of a new nation.
Among its most notable features is the memorial associated with Molly Pitcher, the legendary woman said to have carried water—and possibly manned a cannon—during the Battle of Monmouth. Nearby are burial markers connected to Colonel William Thompson and members of the Armstrong family, anchoring the cemetery as a place where documented history and enduring legend intersect.
Address / Location: 35 East South Street, Carlisle, PA 17013
Access Notes: Downtown Carlisle, east of South Hanover Street. Open daylight hours; walking paths only; respectful behavior required.
Visitor Tips: Free street parking nearby; allow 20–30 minutes
Patriot Story: Mary Ludwig Hays McCauley / “Molly Pitcher”
1754-1832
Mary Ludwig Hays of Carlisle, Pennsylvania, stands among the most enduring—and human—figures of the American Revolution. Like many women who followed the Continental Army, she did not enlist formally, yet her service placed her squarely on the battlefield.
Born around 1754, Mary married barber-turned-artilleryman William Hays in 1777 and accompanied him as a camp follower. Women like Mary cooked, washed, mended clothing, and nursed the sick, forming the essential support system that kept the army functioning. During the sweltering heat of June 28, 1778, at the Battle of Monmouth, Mary carried pitchers of water to exhausted artillery crews—water desperately needed both to cool overheated soldiers and to swab cannon barrels between firings. From this task came the nickname “Molly Pitcher,” a name that would come to represent many women who performed similar work.
According to contemporary accounts and later tradition, when William Hays collapsed (likely from heat exhaustion) Mary stepped forward and took his place at the cannon, continuing to load and fire under enemy pressure. Whether fully literal or shaped by memory, the story reflects a larger truth: women were present in combat zones and, when necessary, crossed the boundary between support and direct action.
After the war, Mary and William Hays returned to Carlisle. William Hays died in 1786. In 1793, Mary married another Revolutionary War veteran named John McCauley. In 1822, the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania granted her a pension in recognition of her Revolutionary service—an extraordinary acknowledgment for a woman of her time. She died in 1832 and is buried in Carlisle.
Mary Hays’s story reminds us that the Revolution was not fought only by generals and soldiers, but by ordinary people—women included—who endured hardship, stepped forward in moments of crisis, and helped carry a young nation through its most fragile hours.
Patriot Story: Brigadier General William Thompson
1736-1781
William Thompson was born in Ireland and emigrated in 1755 to Carlisle, PA. He served as an officer in the French and Indian War, after which he became a business and civic leader in Cumberland County. On June 25, 1775, Thompson accepted a commission from Congress as the first Colonel of the Army of the United Colonies. His unit, originally known as Thompson’s Rifle Battalion, quickly distinguished themselves during the Siege of Boston in 1775–1776. Their sharpshooting skills were critical in harassing British troops and maintained pressure on British positions, eventually forcing the British to evacuate Boston. Recognized for his leadership and effectiveness, Thompson was promoted to Brigadier General in March 1776 and took command of a relief expedition against Canada. On June 8, 1776, the British captured him while leading Continental forces at the Battle of Three-Rivers near Quebec. He was not officially exchanged until October 25, 1780, and he died in ill health on September 3, 1781. He is buried in the Old Carlisle Cemetery on East South Street.
Patriot Story: Major General John Armstrong
October 13, 1717 – March 9, 1795
As a member of the Continental Congress both before and after the Revolutionary War, Major General John Armstrong was deeply involved in the political backbone of the birth of America. Armstrong gained his military reputation during the French and Indian War, where he gained the nickname “Hero of Kittanning” and established his reputation as a strategic leader. He served in the Pennsylvania militia until March 1, 1776, when the Continental Congress appointed him Brigadier General in the Continental Army. He was tasked with the early defense of Charleston, South Carolina against British forces. Armstrong and his soldiers were successful, securing the southern flank early in the war. The troops he commanded later provided essential support during the Battles of Brandywine and Germantown. Armstrong’s military leadership influenced early American defense strategy, and his steadfast leadership shaped the Revolutionary cause in Pennsylvania and other frontier colonies. A surveyor and engineer before the war, he laid out the first plan for Carlisle. Armstrong County, Pennsylvania is named in his honor.
Patriot Story: Chaplain Hugh Henry Brackenridge
1748-1816
Born near Campbeltown, Scotland, he emigrated with his family to York County, Pennsylvania, in 1753 and excelled academically, graduating from the College of New Jersey (now Princeton) in 1771 and earning an M.A. in theology in 1774. Drawn to the patriotic cause, Brackenridge served as a chaplain in the Continental Army, where he delivered patriotic sermons and wrote dramas such as the“Six Political Discourses Founded on the Scriptures” which celebrated American resilience and denounced British rule.
After leaving the army, he edited The United States Magazine in Philadelphia in 1778–79 before studying law under Samuel Chase. Upon completion of his courses, Brackenridge was admitted to the Philadelphia BAR in 1780. Brackenridge then moved to Pittsburgh in 1781, where he became a prominent lawyer, and helped establish the Pittsburgh Gazette and the Pittsburgh Academy (later the University of Pittsburgh). His political career took off at this point in time, culminating into his appointment as a justice of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in 1799. Brackenridge ultimately settled in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, in 1801 and died there on June 25, 1816.
Resources
Cumberland County Historical Society
Cumberland Valley Visitors Bureau
Credits & Permissions
Content in this section was curated by John Bonin, as well as volunteers from the Army Heritage Center Foundation.
